The original idea behind the PCCRC, I thought, was to avoid frequent observations of a position, so I would have time to live my life. My objective was to do a lot of traveling while making money more or less passively.
The PCCRC can make money in several ways. You may have a runaway stock that goes UP 10% or more overnight, making your trade immediately profitable. That is DELTA gains. You may also have stocks that move sideways without the expected rally materializing, and then by the end of the first month, the shorts have lost value, giving you at least some profits. This is Theta gains. It may be that the proximity to a news event or release, may cause the I.V. of the options increase, and you decide to leave the trade, just before the news release. None of these require you to check for Technical analysis signals. You simply wait for an event and just before or after the event, then you leave the trade and take profits. None of these required any knowledge of technical or fundamental analysis.
Now, let's say that the stock rallies, but not overnight, but slow and progressively. Here, your concern is that all rallies come to an end. You don't want to leave the trade prematurely, but you don't want to leave paper profits on the table. What is the right moment to take profits? I suggest you listen to your own gut, or create some rule of some sort, that will allow you to leave the trade without feeling bad if you left too soon. No one can really know what the future holds. What matters is to avoid losses. Note also that it is better to make 10% on your investment in a few days than to make 20% over 5 months. So if a good move has occurred in a very short time, you can take profits by selling calls (if the stock has rallied), or selling puts if the stock has collapsed. In my experience, however, when a stock falls dramatically, it tends to go sideways for a while, or even begin to climb slowly, so it is OK to exit the trade and move on in such cases.
My goal with a PCCRC is to make 20 - 30% for each trade, and to lose no more than 20% in any particular one. This is important to me in terms of money management. I can keep track of 10-15 trades at any particular time. If I have 100,000 to trade, then each one of my trades could be between $7,000 and $10,000. If I lose 20% in a $10,000, I am losing $2,000, or 2% of my capital. I am truly placing only 2% of my capital at risk on any one trade. The PCCRC is hedged in that even in the worse case scenario, I won't lose more than 2% of my capital overnight. But, I know when to exit a trade that is not working out.
It follows that if I make 30% in one trade, I have every reason to exit the position and collect profits. The sooner the better. However, you want to give yourself sufficient time for a strong move in the price of the stock or a big jump in IV to occur, so that profits occurr. You have seen me pick stocks that have jumped 10% or more after earnings. Since we are in earnings season, this may be an excellent time to look for candidates. Take a look at WEBX as an example: The stock was UP more than 10% after earnings, and the company projected increasing earnings above analyst expectations going forward. This after beating expectations by $0.05/share. IV is below 40% and falling, right after earnings. Progressively, IV will begin to climb towards earnings. We want the IV of our long options to increase, while the IV of the short options decline, for Vega gains. The next reporting month for WEBX is July, so we could sell Feb or Mar options, and BUY July options. Going beyond July is fine, but you are buying time you may not need. In the meantime, WEBX may move strongly up in the next few weeks, and give us the Delta gains we want before we exit the trade. Short-term, the stock may go sideways, thus eroding the value of my shorst. Not a bad strategy for those who don't want to focus too much on Technical analysis.
http://biz.yahoo.com/ap/070131/webex_outlook.html?.v=1
I have been quite dogmatic about my IV limits. I don't BUY options with high IV (>40%) and I don't bother with stocks with IV's below 25%. Sometimes, I find stocks with options skews (look at skew finder in Optionetic's Platinum). If I can sell options above 40% and by options at 35%, this may be a pure volatility play. Be sure to test this using Platinum.
Because IV falls after earnings, your exiting position may suffer. Avoid going over earnings if you can. However, if you do, eventually IV's will normalize, so your shorts will lose value quicker but the longs will recover their IV, so don't panic after earnings. Thus, considering exit BEFORE earnings. BUT consider that a strong rally in good earnings may cause an explosion of gains in your position. Before deciding what to do with the trade, I consider how close to the strike price of my position the stock is, what would happen if the stock moves strongly in either direction and assume that IV will collapse.
I recently left a position of GOOG, just before earnings, and I am sure glad I did because my strike price was $500. Drop of IV and stock price is the worse case scenario for the PCCRC. On the other hand, my PCCRC on AMZN had a strike price of $37.5. The stock closed very close to that number of friday. I expect the shorts to lose value very quickly, but the IV of the longs should recover rapidly.
Under any circumstance, earnings are a wild card for ANY options trade. However, if you leave a position just before earnings and the stock rallies, you can always reenter the position at a higher strike price. With any other trade strategy, you can lose all of your investment.
Some of the notes here are in response to questions from our contributer friend PIKO. IF there are further questions, I will address them in the comment sessions to this article. I hope this helps.
For information about joining the private Stock of the Day group, please send an e-mail to Paperprofit1@mac.com
About Me
Blog Archive
Saturday, February 03, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
17 comments:
Thank you Juan for the expository reply on monitoring the PCCRC,
With regard to IV dropping and the stock price dropping, this is a lowish probability condition that can occurs after earnings. Where the speculators are liquidating their options position and a poor earnings rpt causes the price of the stock to drop. Your PCCRC’s are constructed with a bullish bias therefore a bearish drift is going to hurt the position. The IV crush post earnings will continue as people are offloading their options position once the ‘gap’ happens or whatever hedging that the investor wants to do on it. But then if it’s a high flier its only going to be temporary and the IV’s are likely to pick up.
As for those stocks with persistently high IV > 40 for now I will leave them alone as I haven’t test driven them out yet, most of the qws generated were from the regular PCCRC with the conditions that you mentioned.
I had a look at playing IV skews which occur usually just before earnings come out, I find that many would have a pumped up >90day IV as well which would suffer a crush after earnings. Ok given that the front month IV is quite high relative to the back month. And the entry debit is lowered, there is also a potential for gaps after the earnings announcement, its quite a speculative play because we need to factor in the IV crush on the long legs. So far with the superskew finder on list tools in plat there are some nice short term trades with the pccrc which also depends on a gaps to really bring in the profits. The IV skew is useful to cut the debit down but I would not stay in after the crush for more than a day.
Juan you might wanna try shaving the overall trade value in IB by calculating the debit with all ask numbers and see if that allows you to get filled at a better discount.
btw can we put risk graphs and graphics in the comment section?
Piko, if you want to show a risk graph, you can do one of the following:
1. Save it in a Web site of your own, if you have web hosting, and post the address here for people to view.
2. Share it, using Platinum (follow instructions for a share folder with Optionetics platinum).
You could also send it to me, and I will post it if I thought it is in keeping with the material in my blog.
What you did posting the GOOG trade is quite adecuate and I think interested parties can reproduce it in their own Platinum account or other Option's software.
Piko, I tend to agree with much of what you said about the PCCRC around earnings.
Understanding that a volatility crush will occur soon after is very important. However, if you are trapped in a post-earnings decline in IV, don't think you are out of luck. IV DOES come back soon thereafter, while the IV of the short portion of the trade usually stays the same or declines.
I think that the main question would be: do you have sufficient time left on your trade to see a recovery of your gains? Do you really even want to keep the trade on for a while longer instead to putting the capital to work elsewhere?
Just qws on picking at the >90 day IV, if a stock has 2 yr 90 day iv that ranges from 35-45 and the current IV is around high 30’s which is the mid point of the IV range, given the IV/SV is less than 1 how would you assess this trade?
I also came across bryan’s post about price and volume spike. But could not find it on the archives of the blog. Could you point me in the right direction for is method?
I have profit source and it seems to be able to do that.
Hello Juan thanks for your all the work on your blog it's kept me busy for a few nights I've found it quite educational.I put on a demo-trade PCCRC on WEBX 2 days ago and it's looking good so far. When I put it on the IV for March was 2% less than the IV for July.I was wondering if this was stil a candidate or would you only do this trade if the sku was the other way? Would you please explain the criteria details for me also could you please share other potential candidates with entry signals Thank you
Pico said: Just qws on picking at the >90 day IV, if a stock has 2 yr 90 day iv that ranges from 35-45 and the current IV is around high 30’s which is the mid point of the IV range, given the IV/SV is less than 1 how would you assess this trade?
Juan says: Pico, focus on the earnings report. ¿Is your stock reporting BEFORE or AFTER your long options expire? If the options expire AFTER the earnings report, they are likely to increase in value before earnings and decline after that. It makes sense to buy options that will increase in IV as earnings approach. You don't want to sell short-term options less than a month before earnings, because they will cause problems.
IV/SV ratio should be less than 1. If the ratio is about to reverse, as it hooks up, your trade should be a good choice, even if the IV is midway between its historical high and low. Feel free to post your trade for me to comment further. I don't mind talking about specific stocks, as long as you realize that I am no guru that can see the future.
Piko said: I also came across bryan’s post about price and volume spike. But could not find it on the archives of the blog. Could you point me in the right direction for is method?
Juan said; this is one of my long call strategies called "the Sarmiento method" and it is one of my PDF's. Have you downloaded those?
I was wondering if this was stil a candidate or would you only do this trade if the sku was the other way? Would you please explain the criteria details for me also could you please share other potential candidates with entry signals Thank you
I ALMOST always avoid the candidates with high IV in the back month and low IV in the front month.
I ALWAYS avoid candidates with IV above 40%.
I am entering positions on candidates after earnings. I look for 10% gain and improved earnings forecast. That is, not only earnings surprised, but also surprising earnings outlook.
Remember:
You can make money on Delta moves, but also on IV spike in the back month. Feel free to exit a trade whose IV has increased near its highs.
I will discuss the WEBEX example in my next article.
Hi Juan,
out of curiosity, do you use the price vol spike method to put in pccrc trades?
Also where do you find earnings forecasting news?
Well, Piko, I would not rule out using this method.
As long as the conditions are met, and the reason for the volume spike is reasonable, I would consider the PCCRC, instead of owning the stock out right.
BE SURE that the IV conditions outlined here are met. Always backtest this rules before using your money.
Bill Poulos recommends that you paper trade any new method for 3 months before using actual money.
piko said...
Also where do you find earnings forecasting news?
Juan: Try Yahoo financial
HI JUAN,
We just had the Chinese new year here in Singapore and so happy Chinese new year to you.
Here is the eg of the comparison of the PCCRC to the double cal TLJ
Open date 10/2/06 (backtest)
RIMM price at 100.5 after earnings
Long IV 36
Short IV mid 30’s
PCCRC
BTO 4 Jan 100 put call
STO 2 Oct 100 PUT call for 5260 SHAVED
DELTA GAMMA VEGA THETA
46 4 136 6
DCAL TLJ
BTO 4 JAN 100 PUT
BTO 4 JAN 105 CALL
STO 2 OCT 100PUT
STO 2 OCT 105 CALL FOR 4730
DELTA GAMMA VEGA THETA
52 -3 139 3
From the options point of view the Dcal looks better except for the gamma which is in the negative. For the first few weeks of the play the RR is works in favour of the d cal. RIMM gapped up the first few days and we were in profit of 1k for the dcal and 900 for the pccrc.
As the trade progressed and a few rolls ie
10-13-06 roll shorts
10-20-06 sold off 1 straddle of the jan longs to lower the debit. (don’t know what you thingk of this adjustment)
11-9 rolled shorts
now at this point the stock started trending up strongly and the pccrc provided a greater amount of profit. At its peak the pccrc was in 1900 profits and the dcal was about 1780 so at some point if the stock was a strongly trending equity then the pccrc would do better. As for more ‘mundane’ stocks a dcal seems to give you better milage for the money (R/R).
(for the purpose of this eg I forgo the 30% profit taking strategy, deliberately so that we could see how things go when you drive both strategies to its limits.)
IV of the longs went up to about mid 40’s and I closed both trades for
1590 for pcc and 1580 for dcal.
The R/R is better for dcal in the end.
Piko, it seems to me that these two strategies are quite similar. Your attempt at comparing them in a specific situation may be splitting hairs since the RIMM move was quite favorable for both.
My impression is that it is a very good exercise for you to get a feel for the range of potential gains, but many other scenarios may have presented themselves and your RR may have been quite different. So I encourage you to continue your backtesting and not conclude too much from this exercise. To me it is simply annecdotal.
I would have avoided the RIMM play because the IV of the front month was lower than the back month IV. Keep in mind two potential modifications:
1. Once the stock moves UP substantially, take profits by selling some of the long calls, opening yourself for profits to the downside.
2. Once the front month puts lose value and are close to 0, you may sell next month puts without closing current month. Simply let the expire worthless. Only do this 1 week before expiration or less.
BTW, your "D cal TLJ" is selling OTM options, so you are getting less premium for your shorts, albeit your longs are cheaper. Hence the positions overall may be cheaper, but would require stronger moves to be profitable, no?
Sorry to be a bit think, but what is PCCRC? I'm trying to follow along, but I think it'd help if I understood what it stood for :-)
Thanks!
Nicole, and everyone interested, please send me an e-mail requesting my original documents. These are in downloadable PDF's and explain the PCCRC.
This is an advanced strategy and it will take some time to fully understand it. There is a lot of material in this blog. I usually write my articles to make things clearer to my participants. I hope that you will ask all the questions that come to your mind so I can make things clearer.
Orange Country equity investment seeks investments in partnership with experienced business leaders. Able to articulate and execute a clear strategy for their businesses through demonstrated entrepreneurial talents and passion,our management partners are committed to building long-term value through sustained and profitable growth. While our
management teams drive day-to-day execution, Brentwood’s in-house
operational expertise allows us to assist portfolio companies on
selected projects. Our management partners own significant equity
stakes in the businesses they lead, as we believe a highly incentivized
management team is crucial to the success of any investment.
Post a Comment